What 5% more water does to a loaf
I wanted to see for myself how much hydration matters, so I mixed three doughs on the same morning. Same flour (a 12.5% protein bread flour), same starter, 2% salt, and the same schedule. Only the water changed.
| Hydration | Handling | Crumb |
|---|---|---|
| 70% | Easy, holds its shape | Even, a little tight |
| 75% | Tacky but manageable | Open, glossy |
| 80% | Slack, needs wet hands | Very open, flatter loaf |
What I took from it
The jump from 70 to 75 was the one I could taste: the crumb was softer and stayed moist a day longer. Going to 80 gave bigger holes but the loaf spread, and shaping took twice as long. With this flour I am staying at 75.
If your dough feels like soup at a hydration other people find easy, the flour is usually the reason, not your hands. Drop the water by 3 to 5 percent and try again.